The average price for a single family house in Shelby WI is $474,256. 0 listings have accepted offers out of 9 listed (0%). The average square footage is 2,473 sqft. The average price per square foot is $237.00/sqft across all active homes for sale in Shelby.
10-24-2026 - Sort & Search Shelby listings by price, sqft, price per sqft and more. Updated daily.
| View | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| N1177 Breidel Coulee Rd | $749k | 6 | 4 baths | 1.47 | $0 | 3,666 | $205 | View |
| N2062 Wedgewood Dr | $654k | 5 | 4 baths | 5.18 | $6,791 | 3,871 | $169 | View |
| 2778 Hanifl Rd | $649k | 3 | 2 baths | 1.71 | $3,781 | 1,175 | $553 | View |
| N1253 Bloomer Mill Rd | $429k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.93 | $3,572 | 2,585 | $166 | View |
| 3725 Cliffside Dr | $425k | 4 | 2 baths | 0.92 | $4,318 | 2,112 | $201 | View |
| W5240 US Highway 14/61 - | $399k | 3 | 2 baths | 4.76 | $4,176 | 2,006 | $199 | View |
| W4911 Harvest Ln | $389k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.56 | $3,431 | 2,400 | $162 | View |
| W5906 Valley Pkwy | $289k | 5 | 2 baths | 0.24 | $4,246 | 2,300 | $126 | View |
| W5570 State Road 33 - | $279k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.34 | $3,329 | 2,139 | $131 | View |

Get started now on your next transaction in Shelby WI. | Name: |
| Email: | |
| Phone #: | |
| Message: | |
| | |