New Holstein WI
Real Estate
Below is a list of all the real estate in New Holstein including Homes and Condos for sale, as well as Land parcels, Duplexes, Commercial and Multifamily.
New Holstein WI
Real Estate
Below is a list of all the real estate in New Holstein including Homes and Condos for sale, as well as Land parcels, Duplexes, Commercial and Multifamily.
New Holstein WI
Homes for sale
05-01-2026:
Showing 12 homes on the market in New Holstein Wisconsin.The average price for a single family house in New Holstein WI is $687,467.
4 listings have accepted offers out of 12 listed (33%).
The average square footage is 1,994 sqft. The average price per square foot is $687.00/sqft across all active homes for sale in New Holstein.
Galley View | Map View | List View | Sales History
05-01-2026 - Sort & Search New Holstein listings by price, sqft, price per sqft and more. Updated daily.
Press column buttons to sort
use scroll-bar to scroll | View | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| W985 Fur Farm Rd | $1.7M | 3 | 2 baths | 39.31 | $4,976 | 2,349 | $766 | View |
| W1731 Kiel Rd | $1.4M | 5 | 1 baths | 63.67 | $4,927 | 2,435 | $583 | View |
| W1250 County Road HH - | $1.1M | 4 | 2 baths | 31.69 | $7,641 | 2,059 | $572 | View |
| 985 W Fur Farm Rd | $999k | 3 | 2 baths | 10.00 | $4,976 | 2,349 | $425 | View |
| W1858 County Road Q - | $825k | 6 | 2 baths | 19.40 | $7,263 | 3,808 | $217 | View |
| 201 N Irish Rd | $549k | 5 | 1 baths | 16.48 | $2,937 | 2,320 | $237 | View |
| 1925 Park Ave accepted offer | $349k | 4 | 2 baths | 0.50 | $3,813 | 2,226 | $157 | View |
| W197 City View Rd accepted offer | $269k | 3 | 2 baths | 1.00 | $2,314 | 1,602 | $168 | View |
| 1604 Calumet Dr | $234k | 3 | 1 baths | 0.23 | $2,414 | 1,232 | $190 | View |
| 2007 Plymouth St accepted offer | $225k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.36 | $2,936 | 1,134 | $198 | View |
| 2223 Jackson St | $209k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.29 | $2,423 | 1,492 | $141 | View |
| 1717 Jackson St accepted offer | $190k | 3 | 1 baths | 0.26 | $2,569 | 920 | $207 | View |
See all 12 New Holstein Homes for sale
See all Calumet County Real Estate for sale
Land for sale in New Holstein WI
Lt13 Altona Dr New Holstein, WI.Land For Sale 0.00 Acres.$22,750
Listing Broker: NAI Pfefferle - Sheboygan
Offering Broker: Milwaukee Realty Inc.
Lt10 Harding Ave New Holstein, WI.Land For Sale 0.87 Acres.$21,750
Listing Broker: NAI Pfefferle - Sheboygan
Offering Broker: Milwaukee Realty Inc.
Lt2 Kennedy Dr New Holstein, WI.Land For Sale 4.00 Acres.$100,000
Listing Broker: NAI Pfefferle - Sheboygan
Offering Broker: Milwaukee Realty Inc.
Lt1 Kennedy Dr New Holstein, WI.Land For Sale 2.94 Acres.$55,860
Listing Broker: NAI Pfefferle - Sheboygan
Offering Broker: Milwaukee Realty Inc.
Lt3 Kennedy Dr New Holstein, WI.Land For Sale 3.25 Acres.$81,250
Listing Broker: NAI Pfefferle - Sheboygan
Offering Broker: Milwaukee Realty Inc.
Lt3 Tower St New Holstein, WI.Land For Sale 3.90 Acres.$119,000
Listing Broker: NAI Pfefferle - Sheboygan
Offering Broker: Milwaukee Realty Inc.
Lt2 Quality Dr New Holstein, WI.Land For Sale 1.00 Acres.$119,000
Listing Broker: NAI Pfefferle - Sheboygan
Offering Broker: Milwaukee Realty Inc.
Lt3 Tower St New Holstein, WI.Land For Sale 4.31 Acres.$107,750
Listing Broker: NAI Pfefferle - Sheboygan
Offering Broker: Milwaukee Realty Inc.
Lt1-4 Michigan St New Holstein, WI.Land For Sale 0.92 Acres.$46,000
Listing Broker: NAI Pfefferle - Sheboygan
Offering Broker: Milwaukee Realty Inc.
See all 15 New Holstein Land for sale
Including Active with Offers
Condos for sale in New Holstein WI
Robin's Nest1602 Lisa Ln New Holstein, WI.
Condo for sale 2 Beds 2,536 Sqft.$329,900
Listing Broker: CRES
Offering Broker: Milwaukee Realty Inc.
New Holstein WI Duplexes
0 duplexes found at this time.
Commercial Real Estate for sale in New Holstein WI
Business 1702 Wisconsin Ave New Holstein, WI.
Business 3,952 Sqft.$299,900
Listing Broker: CRES
Offering Broker: Milwaukee Realty Inc.
Commercial 1828 Park Ave New Holstein, WI.
Commercial 9,354 Sqft.$890,000
Listing Broker: Adashun Jones Real Estate
Offering Broker: Milwaukee Realty Inc.
Business 2235 Wisconsin Ave New Holstein, WI.
Business 960 Sqft.$229,900
Listing Broker: CRES
Offering Broker: Milwaukee Realty Inc.
New Holstein WI Multifamily
0 Multifamily found at this time.
Get started now on your next transaction in New Holstein WI. | Name: |
| Email: | |
| Phone #: | |
| Message: | |
| | |
You may also call 414-224-7200 or email David@MilwaukeeRealtyInc.com
© 2026, Milwaukee Realty Inc Homes, Condos and Land for sale. Listing Data Source: MetroMLS. Copyright 2026 MetroMLS - All Rights Reserved. Information is supplied by seller and other third parties and has not been verified. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.