The average price for a single family house in Butler WI is $297,560. 1 listings have accepted offers out of 5 listed (20%). The average square footage is 1,332 sqft. The average price per square foot is $297.00/sqft across all active homes for sale in Butler.
10-24-2026 - Sort & Search Butler listings by price, sqft, price per sqft and more. Updated daily.
| View | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12744 W Fairmount Ave | $435k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.32 | $3,127 | 1,940 | $224 | View |
| 4953 N 126th St | $299k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.11 | $3,186 | 1,326 | $226 | View |
| 12418 W Fairmont Ave | $275k | 2 | 2 baths | 0.06 | $3,834 | 1,367 | $201 | View |
| 5053 N 126th St | $255k | 3 | 1 baths | 0.11 | $2,860 | 1,000 | $255 | View |
| 12865 W Lancaster Ave accepted offer | $222k | 2 | 2 baths | 0.30 | $3,207 | 1,028 | $217 | View |

Get started now on your next transaction in Butler WI. | Name: |
| Email: | |
| Phone #: | |
| Message: | |
| | |